Alien: Romulus – 3/5
The Alien franchise is in an odd place of wanting to return to basics, essentially a slasher movie with cooler art direction, a formula that could just be repeated ad infinitum, but still this desire to expand beyond what is. Are you stalker or are you cinematic universe. Mostly, this succeeds as a return to basics, minus the Gen Z cast that feels out of a Facebook ad, this modern idea of what 'cool' looks like. But then it wants to connect to the other films through uncanny valley Ian Holm! And then the alien/human hybrid that looks like the Engineer! I don't mind the Ian Holm in theory; these types of movies work well when there's a whisper of a wider world, something to be curious about but never needing to be discovered. But it's bad visual effects which just remove you from the movie's present in its insistence to fold in the past. And then the Engineer hybrid looks stupid, shades of Alien: Resurrection, and serves as this both more subtle but more obvious attempt to connect to the other, lesser (?) movies which pushed this simple franchise into a more complicated place. I think there's two ways to view worldbuilding: how can you expand this world, and how can you expand what is possible within this world? One is more finite, a way to innovate within limitations. I think it should do more of that.